The colour-coded table above does a poor job of communicating the differences between people's and agents' experiences in the marketplace, because the numbers are averaged out. Here are some examples!...
Example 1: Location Matters
If we compare sales between $750,000 and $1.2M over the past month, days on market vary considerably:
- North East Calgary: 70 days
- Mahogany: 40 days
- West End: 35 days
- Prime Inner City: 20 days
Example 2: Demand Is Differently Sensitive to Price in Different Submarkets
- We have our own apartment for sale in a market with approximately five months of inventory, and the quality/quantity of offers is only loosely connected to its asking price.
- In a detached housing market with approximately three months of inventory (not a huge difference on paper), a listing agent recently priced a home $50,000 below its perceived market value and attracted 15 offers.
Example 3: Changes in Property Values Can Be Surprising
When we read these reports, we see relatively small changes in the median value of detached homes over time. But:
- Some markets have changed enormously. Some apartments, particularly smaller units, are down 25–35% from their peak two years ago, in our experience.
- Conversely, if a desirable home in a particular pocket of the Inner City were to sell today versus three years ago, it could be worth more. New construction homes on full-sized lots are one example.
Example 4: Negotiations Matter
I've never experienced a market in which two seemingly similar negotiations can play out so differently, even within the same submarket, because of the particular preferences and circumstances of the buyers and sellers involved.
Summary
The real differences between and within sub-markets are definitely not easily identified in the statistics we publish. There's lot of value in them, but some risk and opoportunity that comes with relying on them alone:
For example, you might read in our reports that apartment values are falling while detached home values are relatively stable. But it's possible that the outlook for your particular apartment isn't too bad, while the detached home you'd like to purchase is actually falling in value this fall.
Conversely, your apartment might be in a submarket with considerably further to fall (some more luxurious apartments, for example, are firmly in a buyer's market), while the home you'd like to purchase is appreciating because of inventory constraints and strong demand in that particular location and price range.
Please feel free to reach out often, particularly if you you're planning a move in the near term. It's a great time of year to do that anyway.
Changes & Trends This Month:
1) Less confidence: We have noticed a shift in the language of realtors, away from confidence. Typically, agents are pretty resilient, but these days we hear then referring to "this market" quite often. In our opinion "this market" is quite easy to work in as compared to the buyers' markets of our personal pasts, but we do find it an interesting shift in language (from balanced, to negative). As you can see above, it really matters where you operate and in which property types and price ranges, but in general, the language of confidence has been replaced by more buyer's market attitude. This fall, confidence has sort of arced downwards in the industry, and I think that deserves sharing.
Practical use: Townhomes in Altadore may actually be trending up in value but the agent might be a Debbie-downer that doesn't know, so it doesn't hurt to try a low-ball.
2) More international certainty for once: The people have spoken in Alberta and the US, making it certain Alberta will remain in Canada, and more likely Canada will secure a trade agreement with the US, shortly. Importantly, though, how the international oil price (and by extension the interest rate) are managed looks, to me at least, as uncertain as ever.
3) Busier than ever: We never do know how our own professional experience relates to the market as a whole, but if our recent operations do act as a bellweather for next year, we expect a busier year - on both sides. What I mean is, we count our rate and stock of incoming clients for next year (incoming buyer and seller files). At the moment that rate and stock is high for both Breanna and me. Let's see if that experienced is matched by other agents, or if it's just us. We think it's more specific to us, but let's find out.
#1 Agents Across Canada
This month's Insider's Market Report is out now. To create this, we collaborate with some of the best agents from all colours of brokerages all across the country. Tap HERE to find our about how any market in Canada is doing.
If you'd like to be connected with an agent anywhere, please let us know, as we'd love to connect you.